Saturday, April 4, 2015

2015 Lake Junaluska Friends of the Lake 5k Age Group Results

All AGE GROUP RESULTS

2015 Friends of the Lake 5k
Lake Junaluska, NC 4/4/2015 8:30 am Partly Cloudy 58 degrees.
Directed by: Friends of Lake Junaluska, Timed By Right on Time Productions

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 3 MALES

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. NOE RAYA                   29 YADKINVILLE NC          660   17:28  5:38   17:27    0:01
   2. AREK ROBINSON              28 ARDEN NC                588   17:37  5:40   17:35    0:02
   3. TODD DAVIDSON              28 SYLVA NC                525   17:54  5:46   17:52    0:02

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

TOP 3 FEMALES

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. AMY TILLER                 40 CANTON NC               612   22:05  7:07   22:00    0:06
   2. KIMZEY ELLIS               26 CANDLER NC              533   22:51  7:22   22:49    0:03
   3. BLAKE MESSER               37 CANTON NC               572   23:03  7:26   22:59    0:05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 1 - 12 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. MARK MULHOLLAND             9 WAYNESVILLE NC          664   26:14  8:27   26:12    0:03
   2. IANN BALOK                  8 WAYNESVILLE NC          502   35:56 11:34   35:52    0:04
   3. XAVIER HALL                 8 CHARLOTTE NC            668   43:07 13:53   42:51    0:17
   4. DANIEL MARTIN               7 ASHEVILLE NC            567   53:04 17:05   52:49    0:15

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 1 - 12 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. BAILEY PHILLIPS            10 WAYNESVILLE NC          580   37:58 12:14   37:41    0:17
   2. ABBY PHILLIPS               9 WAYNESVILLE NC          579   37:58 12:14   37:41    0:18
   3. EMILY HAWKINS              10 ASHEVILLE NC            547   44:11 14:14   43:58    0:13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 13 - 16 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. ANDREW HAMMEL              14 CLYDE NC                546   18:08  5:50   18:06    0:02
   2. ZACHARY MOORE              13 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       648   21:41  6:59   21:38    0:03
   3. ADAM ROBINS                14 WEST END NC             642   21:57  7:04   21:54    0:03
   4. JACOB BENNINGTON           16 WAYNESVILLE NC          504   22:29  7:14   22:27    0:02
   5. NICOLAS STEPP              13 WAYNESVILLE NC          649   26:13  8:27   26:11    0:02
   6. DANIEL WORLEY              13 CANTON NC               633   27:06  8:44   26:57    0:09

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 13 - 16 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SARAH CLARKE               13 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       514   23:23  7:32   23:17    0:07
   2. ISABELLE YARRINGTON        13 WAYNESVILLE NC          636   26:44  8:36   26:39    0:05
   3. KASSIE JONES               16 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       558   28:30  9:11   28:27    0:04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 17 - 19 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. BRYAN MASSEY               17 WAYNESVILLE NC          569   29:10  9:24   29:07    0:04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 17 - 19 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SAMANTHA MULHOLLAND        18 WAYNESVILLE NC          663   26:03  8:23   26:01    0:03
   2. SYDNEY SINGLETON           18 CANTON NC               597   26:18  8:28   26:13    0:05
   3. MADISON DIETRICH           18 FAIRVIEW NC             528   27:23  8:49   27:17    0:06

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 20 - 24 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. JORGE RIOS                 23 WAYNESVILLE NC          585   20:05  6:28   20:03    0:03
   2. ERIK TVEIDT                24 CLYDE NC                616   23:46  7:39   23:34    0:13
   3. COLTEN JENKINS             22 WAYNESVILLE NC          555   25:52  8:20   25:46    0:07
   4. JESSE DAVIS                23 CANTON NC               661   26:50  8:38   26:38    0:13
   5. TRAVIS GREENE              22 CANTON NC               656   30:36  9:51   30:20    0:16
   6. JOHN MARSHALL              23 WAYNESVILLE NC          644   31:31 10:09   31:27    0:05
   7. JACK BISHOP, III           23 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       506   33:15 10:43   33:03    0:13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 20 - 24 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SHAYNA LEDFORD             21 CHEROKEE NC             563   25:51  8:20   25:47    0:05
   2. LEAH WORLEY                22 CANTON NC               634   27:38  8:54   27:28    0:10

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 25 - 29 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. JUSTIN PHILLIPS            29 WAYNESVILLE NC          657   42:28 13:40   42:15    0:13
   2. GRAHAM EBAUGH              25 WAYNESVILLE NC          531   42:28 13:40   42:16    0:13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 25 - 29 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. KARA DIETRICH              26 FAIRVIEW NC             527   26:42  8:36   26:36    0:06
   2. JESSICA MORGAN             28 SYLVA NC                574   28:16  9:06   28:04    0:13
   3. JENNIFER DAVIDSON          25 SYLVA NC                524   33:06 10:40   32:52    0:15
   4. ELISE DAILEY               25 FRANKLIN NC             523   51:01 16:26   50:56    0:06
   5. DANIELLE WILSON            26 POWELL TN               630   51:02 16:26   50:56    0:06
   6. CLAIRE KIRKPATRICK         27 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       562                          0:14

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 30 - 34 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. DAVID SHORT                32 ASHEVILLE NC            595   18:23  5:55   18:21    0:02
   2. ROBERTO MENA               30 DUBLIN GA               571   18:44  6:02   18:41    0:03
   3. MICHAEL BROWN              34 WAYNESVILLE NC          646   27:27  8:50   27:24    0:04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 30 - 34 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. ERIN SHAW                  34 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       647   27:12  8:46   27:10    0:03
   2. NATALIE COWAN              31 WAYNESVILLE NC          519   27:13  8:46   27:09    0:04
   3. PAMELA STRONG              30 WAYNESVILLE NC          604   30:36  9:51   30:32    0:04
   4. AMY STONEMAN               34 ASHEVILLE NC            601   31:06 10:01   30:58    0:09
   5. MELISSA PETERSON-TINSLEY   32 WAYNESVILLE NC          643   31:31 10:09   31:27    0:05
   6. CHELSEA WHITE              30 CLYDE NC                625   34:35 11:08   34:26    0:10
   7. KELLY EIDELBERG            33 CLYDE NC                532   34:39 11:10   34:24    0:16
   8. KASSIE PHILLIPS            32 WAYNESVILLE NC          581   37:58 12:14   37:41    0:18
   9. GINNY ELLITHORP            32 CUMMING GA              534   39:04 12:35   38:48    0:16
  10. MARISA BROWN               32 CHARLOTTE NC            667   43:06 13:53   42:50    0:17
  11. MARISSA GILLIGAN           32 WAYNESVILLE NC          542   46:54 15:06   46:36    0:18

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 35 - 39 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SETH TEMPLE                39 CLYDE NC                609   22:13  7:09   22:09    0:04
   2. ERIC WIDNER                38 DALLAS GA               627   24:45  7:58   24:38    0:08
   3. MARK SWANGER               37 CLYDE NC                659   28:39  9:14   28:25    0:15
   4. BRYAN GREENE               36 CLYDE NC                655   31:54 10:16   31:39    0:16
   5. ANTHONY COOPER             38 CLYDE NC                516   34:35 11:08   34:26    0:10

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 35 - 39 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. DEIDRA BOONE               39 CLYDE NC                508   23:07  7:27   23:00    0:07
   2. TANYA POOLE                36 CLYDE NC                583   26:08  8:25   26:03    0:05
   3. ABBIE WILKINS              36 WAYNESVILLE NC          651   26:49  8:38   26:46    0:03
   4. AUDRA GAIZIUNAS            38 ASHEVILLE NC            541   32:28 10:27   32:18    0:11
   5. AMBER BOROFF               37 WAYNESVILLE NC          509   32:39 10:31   32:28    0:12
   6. CARMEN WILSON              37 CANDLER NC              629   35:02 11:17   34:48    0:14
   7. MARTHA MARTIN              38 ASHEVILLE NC            568   53:06 17:06   52:51    0:16

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 40 - 44 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SHAWN EARNEST              40 WAYNESVILLE NC          530   24:18  7:50   24:15    0:03
   2. BRIAN DIETRICH             44 FAIRVIEW NC             526   24:54  8:01   24:48    0:07
   3. STEPHEN PALMER             41 WAYNESVILLE NC          578   25:00  8:03   24:57    0:04
   4. ERIC YARRINGTON            42 WAYNESVILLE NC          635   26:44  8:37   26:39    0:05
   5. GLENN WATCHORN             43 WAYNESVILLE NC          623   30:19  9:46   30:11    0:08
   6. SHAWN POPE                 42 CANTON NC               654   32:56 10:36   32:41    0:16
   7. TODD WESSELS               42 DUBUQUE IA              624   37:01 11:55   36:54    0:08

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 40 - 44 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SHERRY STONEMAN            40 WEAVERVILLE NC          603   24:50  8:00   24:48    0:03
   2. MARY RODERICK              41 WAYNESVILLE NC          589   26:08  8:25   26:03    0:06
   3. TANYA JONES                44 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       560   26:44  8:37   26:41    0:04
   4. TRISH MOODY                41 CHARLOTTE NC            658   30:28  9:49   30:21    0:07
   5. TAMI SWIFT                 44 WEAVERVILLE NC          605   32:51 10:35   32:43    0:08
   6. ALISON MOORE               40 WINSTON SALEM NC        573   35:18 11:22   35:10    0:09
   7. CHARLOTTE WARE             44 BELMONT NC              621   35:34 11:27   35:17    0:17
   8. DENICE WATCHORN            42 WAYNESVILLE NC          622   38:03 12:15   37:53    0:10
   9. SHELLEY HAWKINS            41 ASHEVILLE NC            548   43:22 13:58   43:09    0:13

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 45 - 49 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. TODD SWIFT                 45 WEAVERVILLE NC          606   18:22  5:55   18:21    0:02
   2. MARK ROLLINS               48 CLYDE NC                591   22:34  7:16   22:29    0:05
   3. TODD HOKE                  45 HENDERSONVILLE NC       553   23:08  7:27   23:04    0:04
   4. JAY CLARKE                 48 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       513   23:29  7:34   23:22    0:07
   5. WILLIAM CUPRAK             47 LAKE JUNALUSKA NC       522   33:52 10:54   33:42    0:10

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 45 - 49 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. KIM SOLOMON-GAVACH         45 ASHEVILLE NC            599   23:59  7:43   23:52    0:07
   2. LAURA ROLLINS              45 CLYDE NC                590   24:52  8:01   24:48    0:04
   3. SUSAN DIETRICH             47 FAIRVIEW NC             529   27:04  8:43   26:58    0:07
   4. KELLY COWARD               46 CANTON NC               520   29:04  9:22   28:57    0:07
   5. TINA HONERKAMP             46 CLYDE NC                640   29:41  9:34   29:34    0:08
   6. TINA SMITH                 47 CANDLER NC              638   29:42  9:34   29:34    0:08
   7. CHRISTY PACE               46 CLYDE NC                577   32:20 10:25   32:07    0:13
   8. DEBORAH ROBINS             46 WEST END NC             641   33:00 10:38   32:49    0:11

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 50 - 54 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. MIKE ZERRESSEN             54 BREVARD NC              637   19:35  6:18   19:33    0:02
   2. VAUGHN SMITH               53 CANDLER NC              639   23:32  7:35   23:29    0:04
   3. TIMOTHY HUSSEY             54 MAGGIE VALLEY NC        554   24:16  7:49   24:14    0:03
   4. MARK MELROSE               52 WAYNESVILLE NC          662   25:34  8:14   25:29    0:05
   5. RALPH VAN PRAAG            52 ASHEVILLE NC            617   27:31  8:52   27:24    0:07
   6. VERNON TOLLIVER            53 CAMERON NC              613   29:07  9:23   28:53    0:14
   7. SCOTT BOROFF               51 WAYNESVILLE NC          510   34:33 11:08   34:22    0:12

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 50 - 54 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. RAYLENE MORROW             52 BURNSVILLE NC           575   26:27  8:31   26:20    0:08
   2. RITA HENSLEY               51 MARS HILL NC            551   30:32  9:50   30:24    0:09
   3. CHARLENE RUMFELT           53 ENKA NC                 665   31:09 10:02   31:00    0:10
   4. MELANIE SMITH              53 WAYNESVILLE NC          598   32:20 10:25   32:07    0:14
   5. KELLY WARD-SMITH           53 CANTON NC               620   34:00 10:57   33:49    0:12
   6. ELISA GREENBERG            52 WAYNESVILLE NC          545   39:52 12:50   39:42    0:11
   7. BETH GRAY                  54 CANTON NC               544   49:45 16:01   49:31    0:15

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 55 - 59 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. KEVIN FITZGERALD           56 WAYNESVILLE NC          540   18:54  6:05   18:53    0:02
   2. LINCOLN CROSSE             56 ASHEVILLE NC            652   20:52  6:43   20:50    0:02
   3. MIKE BOWLIN                59 LEICESTER NC            511   25:39  8:16   25:34    0:06
   4. MICHAEL COPE               57 CANTON NC               518   32:27 10:27   32:19    0:08
   5. DAVID SINGLETON            56 CANTON NC               596   33:01 10:38   32:56    0:05
   6. MICHAEL WILLIS             56 CANTON NC               628   48:04 15:29   47:44    0:21

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 55 - 59 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SHERRY ROANE               55 ASHEVILLE NC            586   26:29  8:32   26:21    0:09
   2. DONNA COPE                 57 CANTON NC               517   28:34  9:12   28:27    0:08
   3. DEBBY LEWIS                59 ASHEVILLE NC            564   29:21  9:27   29:12    0:10
   4. JANA PLEMMONS              55 PARROTTSVILLE TN        582   32:43 10:32   32:29    0:14
   5. CHRISSY HILL               55 WAYNESVILLE NC          552   34:20 11:03   34:07    0:14

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 60 - 64 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. JOHN TRELEAVEN             63 CANDLER NC              645   22:46  7:20   22:43    0:03
   2. PRESTON JONES              63 MARSHALL NC             559   23:57  7:43   23:49    0:09
   3. STEVE ROBERTSON            62 WAYNESVILLE NC          587   24:32  7:54   24:27    0:06
   4. RICK HEBERT                63 BILTMORE LAKE NC        549   26:12  8:26   26:03    0:09

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 60 - 64 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. GAIL HEINZ                 60 MAGGIE VALLEY NC        550   41:32 13:22   41:29    0:03
   2. JAN VITTUM                 64 SANDY SPRINGS GA        618   42:37 13:44   42:27    0:11
   3. MARGARET ERVIN             61 FORT MILL SC            535   45:59 14:48   45:37    0:22

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 65 - 69 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. PETE DOYLE                 65 MAGGIE VALLEY NC        653   22:37  7:17   22:35    0:03
   2. MIKE TOMKINSON             66 WAYNESVILLE NC          615   26:07  8:25   26:03    0:04
   3. GARY WISE                  69 CANDLER NC              631   34:41 11:10   34:29    0:12
   4. JOHN SCOTT                 66 ELIZABETHTON KY         650   37:31 12:05   37:15    0:17

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 65 - 69 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. ELNORA THOMPSON            67 CHEROKEE NC             610   36:26 11:44   36:20    0:07
   2. KATHIE S MCCRACKEN         65 WAYNESVILLE NC          570   41:05 13:14   40:55    0:11
   3. GAIL STONEMAN              67 WEAVERVILLE NC          602   54:31 17:33   54:20    0:12

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 70 - 74 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. ELVIN KENNEDY              71 CLYDE NC                561   27:40  8:55   27:35    0:06
   2. ROBERT WOOD                72 CANTON NC               632   34:05 10:59   33:50    0:16
   3. GEORGE THOMPSON            71 WAYNESVILLE NC          611   37:55 12:13   37:44    0:12
   4. WAYNE STANKO               73 ASHEVILLE NC            600   39:50 12:49   39:43    0:07

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 70 - 74 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. SUSAN JENKINS              71 WAYNESVILLE NC          556   44:42 14:24   44:31    0:12
   2. SARAH SHERMAN              73 CANTON NC               594   45:58 14:48   45:50    0:09
   3. DONNA COGGINS              70 TUCKASGEE NC            515   49:43 16:00   49:39    0:04

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE AGE GROUP: 75 - 98 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. JIM MAJOR                  76 WAYNESVILLE NC          566   33:21 10:44   33:16    0:05

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE AGE GROUP: 75 - 98 (300)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Place First                     age CITY/STATE              Bib GunTime  Pace TagTime tag off
===== ========================= === ====================== ==== ======= ===== ======= =======
   1. JO AROST                   82 MAGGIE VALLEY NC        501   51:19 16:31   51:06    0:14

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

MALE no age given AGE GROUP: 99 - 99 (** NONE **)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

FEMALE no age given AGE GROUP: 99 - 99 (** NONE **)

---------------------------------------------------------------------------

No comments:

Post a Comment